Check out our creepypasta plush selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our stuffed animals & plushies shops.

Plague Doctor Plush Toy - 10” Glow in The Dark Stuffed Animal - Cute Spooky White Horror Plush - Soft Monster Creepy Plushies - Ideal for Adults or Kids 4.8 out of 5 stars 63

Check out our creepypastas plush selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our stuffed animals & plushies shops.

MrCreepyPasta is available to be your soft, cuddly snd glow in the dark minion of nightly terror for campfire stories, podcast narrations and NonStop Horror Radio evening. Guaranteeing that every night has a nightmare! For more amazing MrCreepyPasta content, Click Here!

Get the best deals for Creepypasta Plush at eBay.com. We have a great online selection at the lowest prices with Fast & Free shipping on many items!

You thought facing the Axe-Wielding dead man was scary? Then how about having him in your own home! in your bed! Now that's nightmare fuel. Get ready for true creepypasta horror with this little plushie replica of eteled made by Sam! how was she able to …

Masky Plushie Creepypasta. Handmade with so much love by Fabro Creations SIZE - 15 Inches Tall *Made to Order *

Unlock nightmare-inducing fun with these adorable Creepypasta Masky & Jeff The Killer Plush Toys! Their soft, cuddly design makes them perfect for hugging, playing, and toting around. Show your love for the horror genre with these delightful handcrafted toys.

Check out our creepypasta toys selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our stuffed animals & plushies shops.